FPHS - Legacy Forum

General Category => Members Discussion Forum => Topic started by: Alan Baker on January 20, 2020, 05:45:42 PM

Title: Daniel CM3 Listings
Post by: Alan Baker on January 20, 2020, 05:45:42 PM
Daniel lists CM3/960 - 976 as relating to Gen Hospitals Nos 1 - 17. I have however come up against several anomalies with this.

I am attaching scans of a postcard and cover from AK's material, both posted in September 1915. The card bears CM3/963 and is franked APO S13, which Proud places at Le Treport at that time. The picture on the reverse is of No Gen Hospital No 3 at Le Treport. However, Daniel lists CM3/963 against No 4 GH.

The cover bears CM3/964 and is franked APO S6, which Proud places at Versailles. Daniel lists this as No 5 GH, which according to the listing on the website The Long Long Trail was at Rouen at the time. The listing gives No 4 GH as being located at Versailles

I have also seen a cover on War Covers with CM3/965 and franked APO S15, located by Proud at Bruyere Camp Rouen. There is a letter inside which is addressed from No 5 GH, although Daniel lists this CM No as from No 6, also at Rouen.

With these apparent anomalies, I wonder if the listing in Daniel has slipped a line, i.e. it should run from 961 - 917. If anyone has any records which would support or disprove this supposition, I should be pleased to hear
Title: Re: Daniel CM3 Listings
Post by: Alan Baker on January 20, 2020, 05:46:15 PM
Here is the cover