FPHS - Legacy Forum

General Category => Members Discussion Forum => Topic started by: dtrapnell on May 21, 2020, 08:04:34 PM

Title: Bethlehem 26 JU 1949 cds on Egyptian adhesives over-printed PALESTINE
Post by: dtrapnell on May 21, 2020, 08:04:34 PM
[size=12pt]Shown here (I hope!) is part of a flagrantly philatelic cover with no address.[/size]
The British mandate ended midnight 14th May 1948. Egypt captured Gaza on 15th & pressed northward. They were in Hebron in September & December 1948 using Egyptian standard adhesives overprinted PALESTINE in Arabic & English (as Gaza).
The history books seem to say nothing about how far from Gaza the Egyptian postal administration extended.
So my Question - Did the Egyptians ever get to Bethlehem - or did an enterprising individual grab their PO handstamp?
Evidence please.
[img][/img]
Title: Re: Bethlehem 26 JU 1949 cds on Egyptian adhesives over-printed PALESTINE
Post by: Alan Baker on May 21, 2020, 10:11:00 PM
According to Wiki, Jordan captured the city of Bethlehem during the 1948 Arab-Israeli War and retained control until the 1967 war.
Title: Re: Bethlehem 26 JU 1949 cds on Egyptian adhesives over-printed PALESTINE
Post by: Alan Baker on May 21, 2020, 10:21:50 PM
I also note that the date on the stamp is 28 Ju 48. which is during a period of truce.
Title: Re: Bethlehem 26 JU 1949 cds on Egyptian adhesives over-printed PALESTINE
Post by: dtrapnell on May 22, 2020, 11:21:35 AM
Thanks for your observation, Alan. I have not found Wiki always reliable, in places even contradicting itself!
As i understand it, the Egyptians plus the Arab Legion pressed toward Jerusalem.
I did not find the bit about a truce in Bethlehem. There was in Jerusalem. Can you direct me?
What we need is other covers (ideally not philatelic & of other dates)!

Has anyone ever seen any?
David
Title: Re: Bethlehem 26 JU 1949 cds on Egyptian adhesives over-printed PALESTINE
Post by: Alan Baker on May 22, 2020, 12:29:40 PM
I found this on Arab-Israeli War 1948 on wiki. There is a map which suggests that Bethlehem was captured by the Arab Legion by the time of the ceasefire on 11th June. Bethlehem is not mentioned specifically however, although a search of the name mentions its capture by Jordan, but no date
Title: Re: Bethlehem 26 JU 1949 cds on Egyptian adhesives over-printed PALESTINE
Post by: dtrapnell on May 22, 2020, 02:37:50 PM
Thanks again.
Wiki is correct in over-all outcome. Jordan occupied East Jerusalem and the whole West Bank. Egypt shrank back to just Gaza.
But how far it got after holding Hebron (whether continuously or not) September to December 1948, we are not told.

I have submitted a short paper with illustrations of Hebron covers to Postal History. Wiki does not mention this specifically.
So, while Wiki is right in the end result, alas it does not say how that was achieved and the intermediate steps involved.

More covers wanted! Postal history can fill the gaps in the history books!
DT
Title: Re: Bethlehem 26 JU 1949 cds on Egyptian adhesives over-printed PALESTINE
Post by: Chris Grimshaw on May 22, 2020, 03:37:33 PM
Hi David

Interesting article and subject.  Have you considered submitting an article to the FPHS Journal.  Something I'd be happy to consider for publication.

Chris
Title: Re: Bethlehem 26 JU 1949 cds on Egyptian adhesives over-printed PALESTINE
Post by: dtrapnell on May 22, 2020, 04:24:05 PM
Thanks Chris.
Yes, I have. I tried to think which publication could pull in the most middle east collectors and, marginally PHS won! I am also going to have it as one of 13 chapters in my book[i] Aspects of war-time Palestinian postal history 1914-1979[/i] (Egyptian Expeditionary Force to Arab-Israeli wars) which is just about finished. It will have one chapter on WW2 Internment Camps by Chris Stephany-Waddell. That too will be published by PHS.

Kind regards        David